So this is a little different from what I usually blog about but here goes...
However, a week or so ago, a contact of mine got in touch about a client that wanted a magazine to be designed for them. They are good at the acquisition of advertising and content, but not so hot on the design parts. I agreed as the money is constant and not half bad.
I did copious amounts of research and I found that there are really two pieces of software that you need in order to do the graphic design for a mag. First, a publishing software, second an image manipulator. The latter is catered for in GIMP, which I use daily anyway and I actually don't mind ( although at the risk of starting a holy war I am not saying it is better than any others, it's just what I am used to). The former was something that I needed to look at. So, what GOOD publishing software can you find.
Well, I narrowed it down further to 4 basic options. They are listed below with a little synopsis:
Adobe products are generally first in any design conversation. People really love Photoshop for image manipulation, and I can't blame them, it does a lot of the leg work for you. I have heard great things about illustrator, and I am sure that for vector based images it is great ( I rarely do this so I don't really know how this program works ). One cannot ignore Dreamweaver either, although I can honestly say that I haven't ever created anything in it as it is a little too magic for my likes.
So InDesign is of a similar ilk. It is a fully featured program that does things for you and is easy to use, although you may need some time set aside to really work out how it works in order to become proficient on it. The thing is, as with MOST Adobe products, you will spend the time wisely as you can do all that you need to do on this program.
The other benefit is that it integrates with the other professional standard programs that we have already mentioned.
The con is as always the price. If this job turns in to doing this sort of thing more often, then I will go for this, if not then I will stick with the cheaper options.
This is another program that gets a lot of great reviews from professional users. The website is clean and the software works well. However, there is one problem that I have with this program and it is similarly reflected in the above option. The price! As far as I can tell this was THE publishing software to have when you were creating mags/books etc back in the day, but then, as always, other software came along. This program HAS I believe moved with the times, but the price is still so high that you would need to be a dedicated fan not to try out the cheaper (although not by much) and more integrated InDesign.
If you create a professional looking magazine in this software, please comment below and tell us how much you sold your soul to the devil for. This is not a horrible software if you need to do something quick and dirty but I cannot see how you could possibly use this to do the "real" work on.
This is an open source software and I should add, the one that I used in the end to get the first edition of the magazine up and running. The software has an adequate reference online and a reasonable interface that allowed me to work through the problems that I came across as an amateur.
There are some REALLY annoying features in Scribus that perhaps I came across as a result of using more than the others and therefore not finding the niggles in the others. One really bad feature is the text box not showing a preview of what the text will look like and being immensely buggy.
However, you over look that sort of thing when you CAN create a professional looking magazine in the time frame and you don't have to pay the earth, or even anything to use the software.
So I am annoyed with things in Scribus and it isn't the quickest way to do the job, but it is the cheapest and until the ground opens up with jobs of this nature, I will most likely stick with it. I appreciate your comments/suggestions as this is really a new area to me!